Melt your candy melts according to package instructions. Take apart cookies.
Next, dip your lollipop stick in a dab of the melted chocolate and press it into the creamy center of the Oreo. Place the top of the cookie back on and refrigerate until solid.
Take your cookie back out of the fridge and dip the entire cookie on a stick back into the chocolate (reheat if it hardens). Cover the entire cookie.
Place prepped marshmallow ears on top of the cookie and then place candy eyeballs somewhere in the middle to middle-top. Finally, add a nose, and you're done! Refrigerate until hardened. Enjoy!
Prep time depends on how many cookie pops you're making. Store in an airtight container.
To make sure the cookies stay together nicely, we like to use Double Stuffed Oreos, but regular also work.
Make sure you prep each cookie pop by dipping the stick in candy melt and securing it inside the Oreo. Then, let them harden up in the fridge for 5- 10 minutes before dipping the rest of the cookie or your pops may fall apart! Yikes!
To keep them from being sticky when touched, we dipped the cut edge of the marshmallow ears in sugar.
We find the smaller size candy eyeballs work best with the size of the Oreo cookie.
For the noses, we use pink Sixlets, but you could use spring colored M&Ms or pink jelly beans.
★ Did you make this recipe? Don't forget to give it a star rating below!